My first work day on sabbatical: reflections on the cost of colonoscopies

Human digestive systemWell, today is the first “work” day of my sabbatical. Because I am in Milwaukee visiting my 92-year-old father there is a hint of vacation in the air, but my body’s muscle memory is telling me to dress for work.

I feel the Void. I must make this day worthwhile.

So I will applaud the new series in the New York Times reporting on “medical mammonism” (my term); otherwise known as The $2.7 Trillion Medical Bill.

The first article uses colonoscopy as an example of inappropriate billing practices. Now, colonoscopies are something I know a bit about, having performed them for 33 years in training and in practice. I have seen the evolution of the procedure and its associated components.

The addition of heavy sedation as delivered by an anesthesiologist is one of the most egregious expenses and is motivated purely by greed.

It is a practice started as an experiment to compare the use of propofol with the standard of “conscious sedation,” the blend of a narcotic and a sedative.

It became apparent that insertion of the tube could be performed a few minutes faster because no adjustment had to be made for the patient’s comfort. In addition, the patient’s memory returned fifteen minutes faster so they could be discharged more quickly. There was no demonstrable medical benefit.

Doctors with private surgery centers quickly embraced these findings because they could book more cases in a day and discharge the last case faster which reduces recovery room expenses.

The gastroenterologists also learned they could hire their own anesthesiologists for less than hospital OR rates and keep a percentage of the anesthesia reimbursements.

The three professional societies that monitor and guide the practice of gastroenterology have all evaluated the use of propofol as administered by anesthesiologists and they have concluded that the expense is not justified for the average patient and they recommend it be used only for exceptional cases.

Yet doctors continue to use it, and more doctors embrace it, because they can make money doing it and they sell it to their patients as “new” and “improved.” Some hospitals and health systems also embrace it for the same reasons.

Trying to maintain good and ethical practices becomes a slippery slope when paired with the commercialization of medicine.

Dr. Steven Nissen said it best in the documentary, Escape Fire: “When we made medicine a business, we lost our moral compass.”

Advertisements

11 thoughts on “My first work day on sabbatical: reflections on the cost of colonoscopies”

  1. We’re in this bizarre situation where no matter how much the colonoscopy costs, we are still charged the $1k deductible. Here in Denver, we can go to the fast, doctor recommended center where you go in, have the test, and to home for $818; or you can check into the the super luxury hospital outpatient center for most of the day at the low cost of $4,500. Either way, it costs us $1k.

    What patient would use the efficient $800 service over the luxury $4,500 service? (Well, I would but I’m a bit of a workaholic.) Because most people have some kind of insurance, there is no incentive for the doctors or hospital to make the procedure easy, and inexpensive for the patient. None.

    I realize this is a bit off your point, but it’s worth noting that these situations don’t occur in a vacuum. Doctors would not get away with “new” and “improved” if their patients couldn’t afford them.

    1. It’s worth noting that this would be my FIRST colonoscopy – my husbands as well. This ridiculousness will continue for the rest of our lives on some regular basis, which frankly, makes the entire thing seem absurd.

  2. Just curious… does Obama Care do anything to help make it any easier for people will be able to make informed choices about their medical care? I recently chose to undergo a spinal injection for back pain without the benefit of conscious sedation because my insurance company would not pay for it. The injection didn’t hurt very much – but didn’t do much good either. I’m glad I didn’t waste money on the sedation.

    1. No. I do not think it has any effect on your question but given thousands of pages of regulations no one can be sure.

      Sent from iPhone. Please excuse abbrvs and typoz (aged thumbs). SPH

  3. Uh oh, I’m realizing we’re going to need a Comments Policy. Takes me back to my days of corporate blogging – the need for disclaimers and what not.

    I’ll say it informally for now. We’ll work on getting something up on the site that’s super official and legal.

    In the meantime, here goes:

    Sam, as an M.D., cannot offer specific recommendations for medical care or treatment to anyone posting a comment on the site. I hope everyone understands. Keep the comments coming. We love them!

  4. Hi Sam,
    Don’t know if you’re familiar with David Sedaris’ writing? In case you’re not – he’s a brilliant, funny, astute, insightful essayist/story-teller. I went to see him speak a few weeks ago in Toronto, and bought his new book “Let’s Explore Diabetes with Owls.”

    The first story, “Dentists Without Borders” is the most dead-on indictment of American medical care that I’ve ever read. Barely reaching seven pages, 100% anecdotal, and taking place entirely in France, it nonetheless gets right to the heart of many of the issues. Do take a look, I guarantee enjoyment. Bizarre that the French would have have done such a good job on national health care, but there it is, they have, who knew. (You may not like the last story as much, about his colonoscopy, but it’s still a great read.)
    Cheers,
    Marcia

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s